1953-1958
Rev. William Crotty
1966-1992
Rev. Aloysius Kuntz
1958-1966
Rev. James Daley
1992-1995
Rev. Gary Szczepanklewicz
1948-53
Rev. John Dempsey
2009-2023
Rev. Todd Remick
1995-2004
Rev. Raymond Donahue
2004-2009
Rev. Bernard Nowak
History of St. Marys, Mayville, NY
Priests serving
St. Mary's
1911-29 Rev. Thomas Harrigan
1929-39 Rev. Timothy Lynch
1939-41 Rev. Charles Rochford
1941-42 Rev. William J. Grant
1942-43 Rev. James Navagh
1943-1946
Rev. Robert D. Duggan
Rev. David V. Roche
Rev. Francis McCormick
1946-47 Rev. John T. Naber
1947-48 Rev. Francis T. Jann
1948-1953 Rev. John Dempsey
(First resident pastor)
1953-1958 Rev. William Crotty
1958-1966 Rev. James Daley
1966-1992 Rev. Aloysius Kuntz
1992-1995 Rev. Gary
Szczepankiewicz
1995Rev. Michael Parker
(Administrator)
1995-2004 Rev. Raymond Donohue
2004-2009 Rev. Bernard U. Nowak
2009-2023 Rev. Todd Remick
2023-Present Rev. David Tourville
2023-Present
Rev. David Tourville